Should you delete a suspended profile and start over?
Almost never. Here's what happens to your reviews if you do, and what Google's rules say about a second profile.
Last reviewed November 20, 2026 against Google's own help pages. Google changes these rules often; if a step doesn't match what you see, trust the help page linked in Sources.
No. Deleting a suspended Google Business Profile and opening a new one almost always leaves you worse off: Google says not to create a new profile for the same business, a duplicate won't show on Search or Maps, and your reviews stay with the old profile instead of following you.
01
Why does starting over feel like the answer?
Because the appeal feels like talking to a wall, and a fresh profile feels like something you control.
Owners in the threads we read ask this one constantly: "If I delete it and start over, do I lose my reviews?"
02
What happens to my reviews in each option?
| What you do | Your reviews | What Google's help pages say |
|---|---|---|
| Appeal and get reinstated | Come back with the profile | Google reinstates the profile along with its owners and managers. |
| Remove the profile from your account | Stay on the old profile, but you no longer manage it | Your posts, photos, videos and review replies are permanently removed. Customer reviews remain. |
| Open a second profile | Start at zero | Do not create a new profile for the same business. A duplicate won't show on Search or Maps. |
| Ask Google to merge two profiles | Combined, if approved | Merges are requested through Google Maps and reviewed. Replies to reviews may be lost. |
03
What does Google say about making a new profile?
In bold on the reinstatement page
It's in bold on the reinstatement page: do not create a new Business Profile for the same business. The guidelines say there should be only one profile per business, and that more than one causes problems with how your information shows on Maps and Search. Google's duplicates page adds that a profile considered a duplicate won't show on Search or Maps at all.
So the new profile you made to escape the suspension is the one most likely to be invisible. And you still have a suspended profile with your name and your reviews on it.
04
What does deleting actually remove?
Google's removal page is specific. Only the primary owner can remove a profile's content and managers, and new owners have to wait 7 days. Once removed:
Your posts, photos, videos and review replies are permanently removed.
Customer reviews and other user content remain.
The business might still show on Search and Maps.
To manage it again, you have to verify the profile again.
In other words
You give up everything you built and keep nothing you need.
If an agency or a former employee is still the primary owner, make yourself Primary Owner before you remove anything.
05
When is a new profile actually right?
When it's a genuinely different business.
A real name change
Google's rebranding rules say a minor name change keeps the same profile, but a real name change counts as a new business: mark the old profile permanently closed, then create the new one.
A second location
Opening a second location with its own staff and its own service area is the other case Google allows.
Buying an existing business isn't one
Google says the previous owner should add you and transfer ownership.
Getting suspended isn't one either
06
What should I do instead?
-
Step 1: Leave the suspended profile alone
No deleting, no new profile.
Done when: one profile, still in your account.
-
Step 2: Read the reason in the appeals tool
It shows the decision and links to the rule. The first 24 hours.
Done when: you know which rule Google points to.
-
Step 3: Fix the profile and gather matching documents
Registration, license, tax certificate and a business utility bill with the profile's name and address.
Done when: one folder, every name and address checked.
-
Step 4: File one appeal
Done when: the status shows Submitted. If it is approved, your reviews come back with the profile.
Start with the first 24 hours, then file the reinstatement appeal. Not sure which problem you have? Read suspended, disabled or restricted.
Other questions owners ask
If I delete my suspended profile, do my reviews go away?
Not exactly, and that's the trap. Google says that when you remove a profile from your account, your own posts, photos, videos and review replies are permanently removed, but customer reviews and other user content remain. You lose control of the profile while the reviews stay attached to it, not to anything new you make.
Can I move my reviews to a new profile?
Not by yourself. The only way Google combines reviews is a merge of duplicate profiles for the same business, which you request through Google Maps and which Google reviews. Google says merged profiles combine their reviews, but replies may be lost.
When is a new profile the right call?
When it is genuinely a new business. Google says that if your business name changes in a way that is not a minor rebrand, it counts as a new business: mark the old profile permanently closed and create a new one. A suspension is not one of those cases.
What if someone else owns my profile and I cannot get in?
Do not make a second one. Google says you can request ownership from the current owner, who has 3 days to respond, and that you may be able to claim the profile if they do not.
Sources (4)
- Google Business Profile Help: Fix suspended or disabled profiles
- Google Business Profile Help: Resolve duplicate profiles & ownership issues
- Google Business Profile Help: Remove a Business Profile from your Google Account
- Google Business Profile Help: Guidelines for representing your business on Google
Why we wrote this. Suspension was the loudest, most emotional problem in our November 2026 study of more than 500 contractor comments and discussions on Reddit, YouTube, trade forums, the Google Business Profile Help Community and agency review sites (how we did the research). Owners kept saying the same thing: the profile disappeared and nobody at Google would explain why. We wrote down the steps that work, checked each one against Google's current help pages, and dated it.
Free, no call needed