How do AI assistants decide which contractor to recommend?
Nobody outside the companies knows the exact formula, and they do not publish one. Here is what they do say, what industry studies add, and what to do with it.
Last reviewed November 20, 2026 against Google's own help pages. Google changes these rules often; if a step doesn't match what you see, trust the help page linked in Sources.
No one outside OpenAI, Google or Anthropic knows exactly how an assistant picks one contractor over another, and none of them publishes a ranking formula for local businesses. What they do document is how the search step works: the assistant searches the web, may use your approximate location, and links to pages it can read. That is enough to know what to keep in good shape.
01
How is an AI answer put together?
Four steps, each backed by a company's own help page. What happens inside the third step is the part nobody publishes.
- Step 1
A customer asks
Something like "who fixes water heaters near me." The assistant may also use an approximate location from the person's IP address.
OpenAI says - Step 2
It searches the web
ChatGPT may rewrite the question into one or more targeted searches. Google's AI features may fan a question out into several related searches.
OpenAI, Google say - Step 3
It chooses what to use
OpenAI says it ranks results using multiple factors for relevant, reliable information. The factors themselves are not published.
Not published - Step 4
It answers with sources
ChatGPT and Claude show citations. Google shows supporting links. OpenAI warns citations can be incomplete or wrong.
All three say
02
What does each company say about local businesses?
In their own words, from their help pages. Where a page is silent, we say so.
OpenAI: ChatGPT search
Search may start automatically. Queries may be rewritten and sent to search providers. An approximate location may be used, and local results may draw on nearby business listings from third-party providers. To be eligible, a site must allow its search bot. Placement is not guaranteed.
Google: AI Overviews and AI Mode
The same foundational SEO best practices apply. A page must be indexed and eligible to show with a snippet to appear as a supporting link, with no additional technical requirements. Google also says to keep Business Profile information up to date.
Anthropic: Claude
Claude searches the web when it helps and includes citations to its sources, so you can check them. Its help page does not describe how it picks local businesses.
'Said' is not the same as 'ranked by'
A company saying a page must be indexed to appear tells you what gets you into the pool. It does not tell you what puts you at the top of the answer. That second part is where agencies often guess and present the guess as fact.
03
What is documented, and what is only claimed?
One row per common claim. The tag shows who stands behind it.
| Claim you may hear | What we found | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Assistants search the live web | OpenAI, Google and Anthropic each describe web search with citations or links. | Company says |
| Your approximate location shapes local answers | OpenAI says it may use an IP-based location, and that adding your city or ZIP helps. | Company says |
| Your site must be crawlable and indexed | OpenAI names its search bot. Google says a page must be indexed and snippet-eligible. | Company says |
| An up-to-date Business Profile helps | Google lists it among the best practices for its AI features. | Google says |
| Reviews decide who an assistant names | No assistant publishes how it uses reviews. Google says reviews help prominence in its own Maps results. | Not published |
| Special code or a secret file gets you recommended | Google says there are no additional requirements. OpenAI says placement is not guaranteed. | Not published |
| You can pay for a spot in the answer | Nothing we found describes it. Google says you cannot pay for a better local ranking. | Not published |
04
What do the industry studies add, and how far can I trust them?
They show how often AI comes up and how often businesses are named. They do not show why.
BrightLocal, 2026 (survey of 1,002 US adults). Use of ChatGPT and other AI tools for local recommendations grew from 6% to 45% in a year and is now the third most-used source. It is self-reported use. It does not say how often contractors are named.
SOCi, 2026 (vendor study). The company reported in a press release that ChatGPT recommended 1.2% of more than 350,000 business locations. These are multi-location brands, so it is not a measure of a one-truck contractor. It shows being named is the exception.
Be wary of precise-sounding rules
Claims like "get 10 reviews a week and ChatGPT will recommend you" are not published by any of the three companies. If a seller states a mechanism as fact, ask where it is documented. Google's complaint form for agencies lists "claims to guarantee top placement in Google Search or Maps" as a violation, which is a fair test for AI claims too.
05
What does that mean for what I do?
Four jobs that match what the companies document. None is a guarantee.
Stay crawlable
Ask whoever runs your site to check that your host or CDN is not blocking search bots, and that robots.txt allows crawling. Google and OpenAI both name this.
Why your site still matters โKeep your profile current
Hours, phone, services and service area. Google lists an up-to-date Business Profile as a best practice for its AI features.
Weekly profile routine โSay what you do and where
One clear page per core service, in text a bot can read, with your town and a phone number. Google says important content must be available in text.
The 30-day plan โEarn real reviews
Not because an assistant publishes a rule about them, but because customers read them and Google counts them in its own results.
Ask for reviews โYour Business Profile and website only help if they are yours. Run the ten-minute ownership check so a former agency cannot take them down, and use the 90-day timeline to judge how long changes take.
Other questions owners ask
How does ChatGPT decide which contractor to recommend?
OpenAI does not publish a formula. It says ChatGPT may search the web automatically, rewrites your question into targeted queries for search providers, may use an approximate location from your IP address, and ranks results using multiple factors to help users find relevant, reliable information. It also says placement is not guaranteed.
Does ChatGPT use my Google Business Profile?
OpenAI does not say. It says ChatGPT may share your location with trusted third-party providers that supply local information such as nearby business listings. It does not name which listings or how they are ranked.
Do reviews affect which businesses AI assistants name?
The companies do not publish how assistants use reviews. Google does say reviews and ratings help a business's prominence in its own local results. Real reviews are worth having for customers either way, since 40% of consumers in BrightLocal's 2026 survey said they trust AI platforms to recommend a business.
Can I pay to be recommended by ChatGPT, Claude or Google AI?
Nothing the companies publish describes a way to pay for a recommendation in an assistant's answer. OpenAI says placement in ChatGPT search is not guaranteed, and Google says there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. Be careful with anyone who promises a spot.
Is AI search replacing Google for local contractors?
Use is growing, but the evidence measures use, not replacement. BrightLocal's 2026 survey reports 45% of consumers used AI for local recommendations, up from 6% a year earlier. Google says AI Overviews are only shown when they add something to classic search, so they often do not appear.
What can I do that Google, OpenAI and Anthropic all point to?
Keep your site crawlable and your pages indexed, keep your Business Profile accurate and current, and say clearly on your site what you do and where. None of these is a guarantee. They are the things the companies' own pages describe.
Sources (8)
- OpenAI Help Center: Searching the web with ChatGPT
- Claude Help Center: Enable and use web search
- Google Search Central: AI features and your website
- Google Search Central: Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content
- Google Business Profile Help: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google
- Google Business Profile: Third party complaint, report a violation
- BrightLocal: Local Consumer Review Survey 2026 (1,002 US adults, SurveyMonkey panel)
- SOCi 2026 Local Visibility Index, as published in a March 10, 2026 press release (vendor study of multi-location brands)
Why we wrote this. Owners in our November 2026 study of more than 500 contractor comments and discussions kept asking whether they could skip the agency and do it themselves with AI (how we did the research). We checked every Google, OpenAI and Anthropic statement on this page against that company's own help page and dated it. Anything that comes from an industry study is labelled as one.
Free, no call needed