Meta Pixel
Warning signs

9 signs your SEO company isn't doing the work

The patterns owners describe again and again, how to spot each one yourself, and what to do next.

8 min read Updated November 20, 2026
A phone and a coffee cup sit on a truck dashboard with an empty suburban street ahead at dusk.

The clearest sign your SEO company isn't doing the work is a monthly report with no list of changes you can click on. Add not owning your own accounts and numbers that don't match your books, and you are paying for reports, not results.

01

The 9 signs at a glance

#SignWhat to do
1
You get reports, but never a list of changes
Ask in writing for every change last month, with links. Give them a week.
2
You don't own your own logins
Ask to be made owner on each account now, while things are friendly.
3
They rank you for searches nobody types
Ask how many people search each phrase a month, in your towns.
4
Their numbers don't match your books
Ask for the list behind the number: date, name, job. Match it yourself.
5
The calls are junk
Listen to a week of tracked calls. Ask what they are doing to filter junk.
6
A new account manager every few months
Ask who does the work, not who manages the account, and for a direct line.
7
"SEO takes 12 months", with nothing to show at month two
Slow results are normal. Invisible work is not. Ask for the work, not the results.
8
Your Google profile looks the same as last year
Ask for new photos, updates and review replies every month.
9
They promise rankings, or can't explain anything in plain English
Google warns owners about exactly this. Treat it as a reason to leave.

02

Signs 1 to 3: no work, no access, wrong searches

1. You get reports, but never a list of changes

What it looks like: Monthly graphs and scores. Ask what changed and you hear "we optimized your site".

Send this: "Please list every change you made to my website and Google profile in [month], with a link to each, by Friday."

A good reply: It arrives within a day or two, fits on one page, and every link opens something you can see.

2. You don't own your own logins

What it looks like: Your Google profile, website, domain or ad account sits in their name. You get reports instead of access.

Send this: "Please add me as owner on my Google Business Profile, Search Console, Analytics and domain this week. Keep yourselves as managers."

A good reply: "Done, check your email for the invites." Ownership should never need a meeting.

Business Profile
Your Business Name
YOwner1Owner, not a guest
MManager2Their company: manager
What you want to see: you as the owner, your marketing company added as a manager. Check Search Console and Analytics the same way. Illustration built from Google's help page, so labels may look slightly different on your screen.

3. They rank you for searches nobody types

What it looks like: A long list of first-page rankings for odd phrases, and a quiet phone.

Send this: "For each keyword in the report, how many people search it a month in the towns I serve?"

A good reply: A short table with real search numbers, and a plan to chase the searches that matter.

The complaint we heard most

These three are the core of the complaint we heard most from owners: paying $2,500 to $3,500 a month and getting graphs instead of changes. If you only check one thing, check the list of changes. The guide to what should change every month shows what a real list includes.

03

Signs 4 to 6: numbers, calls and people

4. Their numbers don't match your books

What it looks like: "Leads" or "closed revenue" you can't find in your own records. One owner saw a $5,000 job reported as $15,000.

Send this: "Please send the list behind last month's leads and revenue: date, caller, and what it turned into."

A good reply: A list you can match line by line to your own job records, with spam marked as spam.

5. The calls are junk

What it looks like: Spam, sales pitches and wrong-service calls. One owner found ad money spent on calls meant for chiropractors and dentists.

Send this: "How many of last month's tracked calls were spam, sales or the wrong service, and what are you changing to cut them?"

A good reply: A straight count, a few examples, and one specific change (a filter, a new keyword exclusion, a fixed listing).

6. A new account manager every few months

What it looks like: Each new person needs the story again. One owner went through five in three months.

Send this: "Who actually does the work on my account, and how do I reach that person directly?"

A good reply: One name, a direct number or email, and an answer to your next question the same week.

When the two disagree

Reports count what the tool can count. Your books count what paid. When the two disagree, your books win. The guide to reading an SEO report explains which numbers to trust.

04

Signs 7 to 9: excuses, a stale profile and promises

7. "SEO takes 12 months", with nothing to show at month two

What it looks like: Time is the answer to every question, but nothing visible has changed either.

Send this: "I understand results take time. What work did you do in months one and two, and where can I see it?"

A good reply: Links to pages, photos and fixes from both months. "Trust the process" is not an answer.

8. Your Google profile looks the same as last year

What it looks like: Same photos, no updates, reviews unanswered.

Send this: "What photos, updates and review replies will you add to my Google profile this month, and by when?"

A good reply: A short list with dates, and a request for photos from your recent jobs.

Business Profile
Your Business Name
1Newest photos from real jobs
Updates2New updates this month
Reviews3Replies on recent reviews
Open your profile and look at the photos, updates and reviews. If they match last year, that is your answer. Illustration built from Google's help page, so labels may look slightly different on your screen.

9. They promise rankings, or can't explain anything in plain English

What it looks like: Guaranteed page one, a "special relationship" with Google, secret methods.

Send this: "Can you explain, in two sentences, what you will do next month and why it should bring calls?"

A good reply: Two plain sentences you could repeat to your crew. No guarantees, no secrets, no "special relationship".

On sign 7

Google's own SEO Starter Guide says some changes take hours and others several months, so patience is fair. Invisible work is not.

On sign 9

Google is blunt. Its advice to owners says no one can guarantee a number one ranking, to beware of anyone claiming a special relationship with Google, and to be careful if a company won't clearly explain what it intends to do.

05

I see several of these. What now?

What you'll need
Your contract, last few reports, and a list of your logins.
Time it takes
An hour to write it up, then 30 days to see if it gets fixed.
Done looks like
You either have visible monthly work, or a written record and a clean exit.
  1. Step 1: Count the signs.

    Go through the nine signs above and tick every one that fits. Be honest: one bad month is not a pattern.

  2. Step 2: Put it in writing.

    Email your marketing company the signs you found, with examples, and ask what they will fix and by when.

  3. Step 3: Secure your accounts.

    Before anything else changes, make sure you are owner on your Google profile, Search Console, Analytics and domain.

  4. Step 4: Give it a deadline.

    Thirty days is fair for visible work to show up. Write the date down.

  5. Step 5: Decide.

    If the work shows up, keep checking monthly. If it doesn't, cancel in writing and, where you have a case, ask for a refund.

If it comes to leaving

If it comes to leaving, how to ask for a refund has a letter you can copy, and the 15-question scorecard helps you pick the next company.

Questions owners ask

How do I know if my SEO company is scamming me?

Look for three things together: no list of changes behind the monthly bill, no access to your own accounts, and numbers you can't match to real calls or jobs. Any one can be a bad month. All three together is a pattern worth acting on.

Is it normal for SEO to show no results for months?

In our experience calls can take a few months, especially in a crowded market. Work should not. You should see changes on your site and Google profile from the first month. Google itself says some changes take effect in hours and others take several months.

What do I do if my SEO company won't give me my Google Business Profile?

Ask in writing to be made Primary Owner. Keep a copy. If they refuse, Google Business Profile Help has a "request ownership" process for a profile someone else controls.

Should I cancel my SEO contract if I see these signs?

Put the problems in writing first and give a deadline. If nothing changes, cancel in writing. Read the cancellation terms before you send it, and secure every login before you do.

Can a marketing company guarantee first place on Google?

No. Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and to beware of anyone who claims to, or who claims a special relationship with Google.

Why we wrote this. In November 2026 we read 33 Reddit threads in full, about 510 YouTube comment threads and the agency complaints on BBB and Trustpilot, all from trades owners talking about Google and marketing companies. "I paid and got reports, not results" and "I can't tell if they're doing anything" were two of the loudest complaints. This library answers the questions those owners asked, in their words. Owner stories are paraphrased and left unnamed.

Written by Alex Rocha. Last reviewed November 20, 2026.

Alex Rocha

About the author

Alex Rocha

Founder of Mastodon Marketing, a Houston-based marketing agency for home services and contractors, founded in 2022. Alex has 15+ years of operator and agency experience building growth systems for businesses across Greater Houston and Texas.

Want a second pair of eyes?

Want a second pair of eyes?

Send us your Google Business Profile and we'll record a free teardown: what is helping, what is hurting and what we'd fix first. No contract, no sales sequence. Get the free GBP teardown.

Want help applying this?

Tell us your bottleneck. 15 minutes, honest.

Book a Fit Call โ†’