Meta Pixel
Checklist + printable scorecard

15 questions to ask before you hire a contractor marketing company

The questions that expose lock-in, vague work and fuzzy reporting before you sign, with the answer you want to hear and a printable scorecard.

8 min read Updated November 20, 2026
Two men in navy work jackets sit facing a window across a conference table with coffee cups and notebooks.

Before you hire a marketing company, ask who will own your website and Google profile, what exactly they will change each month, how they will prove it, and how you get out. The 15 questions below, and the printable scorecard, turn a sales call into something you can compare side by side.

01

Why ask before you sign?

Because the problems owners complain about most are all visible before the contract, if you know where to look.

Lock-in

The angriest stories we read were about lock-in: an agency that kept Primary Owner on a Google profile after three written requests, a site the owner paid for that disappeared when they left, contracts that were "month to month" until the owner tried to cancel.

The work

The next most common were about the work: monthly invoices with no changes on the site and a report that said things were improving.

What a good answer sounds like

A good company will answer every question below in plain English without flinching. A company that can't name its work will steer back to rankings and price. Google itself says to interview any SEO before you hire, and to be careful if a company is secretive or won't clearly explain what they intend to do.

02

Who owns what: questions 1 to 4

#Ask thisWant to hearWalk away if
1 Will my website, domain and Google Business Profile be in my name from day one?
Yes. You own them; we're added as managers. You can remove us any day.
We host it on our platform. We'll transfer it if you leave (for a fee).
2 Will I have owner access to Google Analytics, Search Console and any ad accounts?
Yes, you're the owner and we'll show you how to log in on the first call.
We send you reports, so you won't need logins.
3 If I leave, what do I walk away with?
Everything: the site files, the content, the photos, the accounts and the phone numbers.
The content is licensed while you're a client.
4 Whose name is on the call tracking numbers?
Yours, or we port them to you when you leave.
Ours. They stop working when the contract ends.

03

The work: questions 5 to 8

#Ask thisWant to hearWalk away if
5 What exactly will you change in the first 30 days?
A named list: these pages, these profile fixes, these listings, by this date.
We start with a strategy phase and optimize from there.
6 What will you do every month after that?
Specific, countable work you'll be able to click on: pages, photos, posts, reviews follow-up, listing fixes.
Ongoing SEO, link building and optimization.
7 Can you show me two or three contractors you've done this for, and can I call one?
Here are three, here's a phone number, ask them anything.
Our clients are confidential.
8 Who will actually do the work, and who do I call when I have a question?
One named person, a direct number, an answer the same week.
You'll have a dedicated account manager (who changes every few months).

04

Proof and reports: questions 9 to 12

#Ask thisWant to hearWalk away if
9 What will your monthly report show me?
What we changed, with links; calls and forms we can trace to it; what's next.
Rankings, traffic, impressions and a health score.
10 How will you count calls, and will you show me the spam ones too?
Tracked numbers and forms, every call listed, junk marked as junk.
We count all leads generated.
11 Which searches will you report rankings for, and do real customers type them?
Searches your customers use in the towns you serve, and we'll show you the search numbers.
We track 200 keywords.
12 What results do you expect, and by when?
Visible work in month one; here's what we'd expect to see by month three, and how we'll measure it.
Guaranteed page one, or guaranteed leads.

05

The contract: questions 13 to 15

#Ask thisWant to hearWalk away if
13 Can I cancel any month, and how do I cancel?
Yes, month to month. Send one email. No fee.
It's a 12-month agreement, but it's really month to month after that.
14 Does the contract renew on its own?
No. Or: it's month to month, so there's nothing to renew.
It auto-renews unless you cancel in writing 60 days before.
15 What happens to my money if you don't do the work you listed?
The monthly deliverables are in writing. If we miss them, we credit that month or make it up, in writing.
SEO takes time, so results can't be guaranteed.

06

How do I score the answers?

What you'll need
The printable scorecard, a pen and the company's draft contract.
Time it takes
About 30 minutes per company, on the sales call.
Done looks like
Every company has a score out of 30, and the good answers are in the contract you sign.
  1. Step 1: Print the scorecard, one copy per company.

    Download the printable scorecard (PDF). Bring it to every sales call so each company answers the same 15 questions.

  2. Step 2: Ask every question, in order, and write down the answer.

    Do not let the salesperson skip ahead to pricing. If they can't answer a question on the call, ask them to answer it in writing.

  3. Step 3: Score each answer 2, 1 or 0.

    2 means the answer matches the "want to hear" column, in writing. 1 means it is close but vague. 0 means it matches the "walk away" column or they wouldn't answer.

  4. Step 4: Add it up and check the deal-breakers.

    24 or more out of 30 is a company worth talking to. Under 18, keep looking. A 0 on questions 1, 3 or 13 is a deal-breaker no matter the total.

  5. Step 5: Get the good answers into the contract.

    A promise on a sales call is not a promise. Ask for the ownership terms, the monthly deliverables and the cancellation terms in the signed agreement.

Printable · PDF

Download the printable scorecard (PDF)

PDF

Download Download the printable scorecard (PDF)

07

What does Google say to ask?

Google publishes its own advice for business owners hiring an SEO. Its suggested interview questions include asking for:

Examples of past work

Whether they follow Google's rules

What results they expect and in what timeframe

Their experience in your industry and your city

Whether they will share every change they make to your site

What the same page warns about

The same page warns that no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and to be wary of anyone who claims a "special relationship" with Google or emails you out of the blue. It also reminds owners that you are responsible for what any company you hire does to your site. You can read the full list on Google's "Do you need an SEO?" page.

Already signed with someone?

Use the same questions as a check-up, then run the five checks in how to tell if your marketing company is doing anything.

Questions owners ask

What questions should I ask before hiring a marketing company?

Ask who will own your website, domain and Google profile; exactly what they will change in the first 30 days and every month after; who does the work; what the monthly report shows; how they count calls; and how you cancel. The 15 questions on this page cover all of it, with the answer you want to hear for each.

What is the biggest red flag when hiring an SEO company?

A guarantee of rankings or leads. Google's own advice is that no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and to beware of anyone who claims to, or claims a special relationship with Google. The second biggest is the agency owning your website or Google profile.

Should I sign a 12-month marketing contract?

Be careful. Long lock-ins and auto-renewals are among the most common owner complaints about marketing companies. Month to month keeps a company earning your business every month. If you do sign a term, get the deliverables and the exit terms in writing.

Is a marketing company that only works with contractors better?

Not automatically. Google suggests asking any SEO about their experience in your industry and your city. What matters more is whether they can show you real work for businesses like yours and let you call one of those owners.

How do I check a marketing company's references?

Ask for two or three current clients in the trades and call them. Ask what changed on their site last month, whether they own their accounts, and how fast the company answers. Google's guidance also says to check an SEO's business references.

Why we wrote this. In November 2026 we read 33 Reddit threads in full, about 510 YouTube comment threads and the agency complaints on BBB and Trustpilot, all from trades owners talking about Google and marketing companies. "I paid and got reports, not results" and "I can't tell if they're doing anything" were two of the loudest complaints. This library answers the questions those owners asked, in their words. Owner stories are paraphrased and left unnamed.

Written by Alex Rocha. Last reviewed November 20, 2026.

Alex Rocha

About the author

Alex Rocha

Founder of Mastodon Marketing, a Houston-based marketing agency for home services and contractors, founded in 2022. Alex has 15+ years of operator and agency experience building growth systems for businesses across Greater Houston and Texas.

Want a second pair of eyes?

Want a second pair of eyes?

Send us your Google Business Profile and we'll record a free teardown: what is helping, what is hurting and what we'd fix first. No contract, no sales sequence. Get the free GBP teardown.

Want help applying this?

Tell us your bottleneck. 15 minutes, honest.

Book a Fit Call →