Switching marketing companies without losing your rankings or your phone number
Owners stay with a company they're unhappy with because they're scared of what breaks on the way out. Most of it is avoidable if you do things in the right order. Here's the order.
To switch marketing companies safely, take ownership of your accounts first, get a full copy of your website and a list of every phone number, keep your web page addresses the same on the new host, and only then send notice. The things that hurt rankings in a switch are a site that goes down, pages that change address without redirects, and lost phone numbers, not the switch itself.
01
What actually breaks when you switch marketing companies?
Switching companies doesn't hurt your rankings by itself. What does is what happens to your website and Google profile during the switch, which is why Google publishes step-by-step guidance for site moves. The usual damage:
The website goes dark
because it lived on the agency's hosting and was switched off on the last day.
Pages change address
when the new company rebuilds the site, and nobody points the old addresses at the new ones.
Tracking numbers stop ringing
because they belonged to the agency's call tracking account.
Ads stop
because billing ran through the agency.
You lose your history
because analytics and Search Console were in their name.
Every one of these is fixed by doing things before you give notice, not after.
02
Week 1: what should I do before anyone knows I'm leaving?
-
Step 1: Week 1: list everything and take ownership
Use these guides:
-
Step 2: Week 1: find every phone number
List every number on your Google profile, website, ads and directories, and who provides each one. Ask the agency which ones they own and whether they can be ported to you.
Not sure the company is failing you? Run the five checks in how to tell if your marketing company is doing anything before you decide to leave.
03
How do I keep my phone numbers?
Split your numbers into two groups.
Your main business number, as long as it's in your own phone account, stays yours whatever happens with the agency. Make sure it's the primary number on your Google profile.
Tracking numbers are the extra numbers an agency puts on your ads, website or listings to count calls. They usually sit in the agency's or the tracking company's account. For each one, ask: can it be ported to a provider in my name? If yes, start the port with your new provider before your end date.
Porting a number
The FCC's porting guide says to start with the new company and not to cancel the old service first. That guide is written for consumers, so for business lines confirm the process with the new provider.
If a number can't come with you
If a tracking number can't come with you, switch your listings back to your main number before the end date, so customers who saved the old one aren't the only ones calling a dead line.
04
Week 2: how do I move the website without hurting rankings?
Rebuilding the site?
If your new company wants to rebuild the site, that's fine, but ask for the redirect list before launch day, in writing.
-
Step 3: Week 2: get a full copy of the website
Get the site files or an export, the hosting login or a plan to move hosting, and the DNS records. Decide who will host it next.
-
Step 4: Week 2: plan the move so web addresses stay the same
If the new host keeps every page at the same address, rankings have the least to react to. If addresses must change, map each old address to its new one with permanent redirects.
Google has separate guidance for each case.
For a hosting move where addresses stay the same, it says to:
- copy and test the site on the new host first,
- lower the domain's DNS refresh time (the TTL) at least a week ahead,
- and keep your Search Console verification file or tag on the new copy.
For a move where addresses change, it says to:
- use permanent (301) redirects from each old address to its new one
- and keep them for at least a year.
05
Weeks 3 and 4: how do I hand off and switch over?
Ads billing
For ads, set up your own billing before removing the agency's manager account. Google says unlinking a manager that pays on monthly invoicing stops your ads.
-
Step 5: Week 3: send the cancellation letter
Use the cancellation letter template. Its numbered list doubles as the handover checklist.
-
Step 6: Week 4 (or your contract's end date, if later): switch over
Move hosting, port numbers, remove old users, and check the site, forms, calls, email and Google profile the same day. Then watch calls and Search Console for a month.
Switch-over day checklist:
- Website loads on a phone and a computer, at the same addresses as before.
- Contact form sends to your inbox. Send a test.
- Every number on the site and Google profile rings through. Call each one.
- Business email sends and receives.
- You're Primary Owner on the Google profile, and the old company is removed.
- Search Console shows the site with no new errors a week later.
Hand-off week is also a good time to go through the suspension-proof setup checklist for your Google profile.
Questions owners ask
Will I lose my Google rankings if I switch SEO companies?
Switching who does the work doesn't hurt your rankings by itself. What causes drops during a switch is the website going down, pages disappearing or changing address without redirects, or big changes to your Google profile. Keep the site up, keep web addresses the same where you can, and the switch should be quiet.
Can I keep my phone number when I leave my marketing company?
Your main business number, if it's with your own phone company, stays yours. Tracking numbers the agency set up are often in the agency's or the tracking company's account. Ask whether each one can be ported to you. The FCC's porting guide says to start a port with the new provider and not to cancel the old service first.
How much notice should I give before switching marketing companies?
Whatever your contract requires, usually 30 days. Start the ownership steps a week or two before you send notice, so the handover isn't the first time you ask for access.
Should the new marketing company talk to the old one?
It helps for the technical handover (website files, hosting, DNS), but you should hold the logins, not the new agency. Introduce them by email with yourself copied, and keep every account in your name.
What should I check the day after switching?
Your website loads on phone and computer, the contact form arrives in your inbox, every phone number on your site and Google profile rings through, your business email works, and you're still Primary Owner on your Google profile.
Sources (5)
- Google Search Central: Changing your web hosting and SEO (moving without URL changes)
- Google Search Central: Site moves and migrations (moving with URL changes)
- FCC: Porting, keeping your phone number when you change providers
- Search Console Help: Verify your site ownership
- Google Ads Help: About unlinking accounts from your manager account
Why we wrote this: in a November 2026 study of what trades owners say about marketing (Reddit, contractor forums, YouTube comments and agency reviews), "they own my stuff and I can't get out" was one of the angriest complaints. Owner stories on this page are paraphrased and unnamed. Last reviewed November 20, 2026 by Alex Rocha. Google and registrar screens change; if a step here no longer matches what you see, the linked help page is the final word.
Want a second set of eyes?
Want a second set of eyes?
Our free Google listing teardown is a real person going through your Google profile the way a customer would and sending you the fixes, ranked. No contract, and nothing to log in to.
Want help applying this?
Tell us your bottleneck. 15 minutes, honest.